Behind the Paddle
Welcome to "Behind the Paddle", the podcast that explores the fascinating world of sex across a wide spectrum of topics; from LGBTQ+ and feminine power, to kink, sex work and the adult industry. We aim to inform, inspire and entertain, featuring expert interviews, compelling stories, and thought provoking discussions.
Join Porcelain Victoria (a very experienced Pro-Dominatrix of 9yrs) on a funny and wonderfully truthful look at the world through the lens of a BDSM practitioner working in the sex industry.
She will also be answering listeners questions about real-life queries which will be discussed on the podcast. These can be sent in via email or through any
socials.
Email: behindthepaddlepodcast(at)gmail.com
Our socials: https://allmylinks.com/behindthepaddle
Behind the Paddle
E139:CNC - Take me with force, excitement, uncertainty and Consent
Want to suggest a topic or simply say Hello ? Send a message here !
Why would someone fantasise about losing control? And why can the idea of something forbidden become sexually exciting?
In this episode of Behind the Paddle, we're exploring one of BDSM's most misunderstood and controversial subjects: consensual non-consent, or CNC.
From fantasies of surrender and powerlessness to the psychology of taboo, dominance and control, we delve into why some people find these scenarios arousing, what they might represent psychologically, and why fantasy doesn't necessarily reflect what someone wants in reality.
We'll also discuss the crucial distinction between consensual roleplay and sexual violence, the responsibilities involved in exploring CNC, and why communication, boundaries and trust are absolutely essential.
WORKSHOPS
SEX WORK 101
https://www.trybooking.com/uk/HEUI
PROFFESIONAL DOMINATION 101
https://www.trybooking.com/uk/HEUK
CONFIDENCE & GUIDANCE
https://www.trybooking.com/uk/HGZG
Check out our socials!
Thank you so much for listening 💖
So today we're about to talk about one of the more controversial areas of BDSM. Consensual non consent, otherwise known as CNC. Now, even a name sounds like a contradiction. How can something be consensual if the whole fantasy revolves around not consenting? And that's what makes this kink much more interesting, at least that's what I think, and a whole bunch of other people. Because we're talking about about people who may fantasize about being overpowered, having control taken away, or being placed in situations where they appear to have no choice. But the crucial word here is fantasize. There's a massive difference between somebody wanting to experience a negotiated fantasy and somebody actually wanting to be assaulted. And I think that's something people really struggle to understand when it comes to CNC. I think there definitely needs to be more education on it rather than people, especially people who aren't kinky, just slapping on a big red warning sign saying CNC is really dangerous or BDSM is really dangerous when they haven't tried it with somebody who's experienced, they do not know the community, they don't understand it, they don't have a liking for it. I get it, BDSM just in general isn't always somebody's cup of tea, but it doesn't mean it needs to be outright banned or shamed. Because if people don't know, I myself am a sex worker and there was a UK ban, which hopefully will be overturned at some point, that came into play on the 6th of November, where we can't sex workers or partners cannot record or share face-sitting videos or deep throating penis or strap-on. Anything that blocks the airway uh airways in some way. We can't do that. It sounds ridiculous because it is. And I fear that this is just going to absolutely snowball and spiral within the UK. Everything has such a domino effect, and now the government have said any under 16s, I believe it is, can't use um depop eBay vintage, I believe it's under 16s. Which is crazy that you could go to jail for letting your child even look on eBay. It's insane, it really is. And then you know, we've got um digital ID, the government's trying to tax us loads no matter what. Not taxing the millionaires or the billionaires or anything like that. No, it's it's so horrendous. Uh but yeah, CNC. But yeah, CNC. People hear about these fantasies and immediately start making assumptions. They assume the person must have experienced trauma, that there's something physiologically wrong with them, or that they secretly want something terrible to happen. But human sexuality is rarely that straightforward. Which I feel like we've talked about a lot on this just this podcast, is how fluctuating our kinks can be and just our lives can be within that. So I want to explore what CNC, consensual non-consent, actually is, why people might find these fantasies appealing, what psychology tells us, and why having a forbidden fantasy doesn't necessarily say anything about what you'd want in real life. Consensual non-consent is a form of BDSM role play in which people negotiate a scenario that simulates a lack of consent, resistance or control. That might involve fantasies of being pursued, captured, overpowered, or otherwise placed in a situation where someone appears to have no choice. But the important distinction is that the participants have agreed to the scenario beforehand, within specific boundaries, and retain the right to stop. The fantasies might involve somebody appearing powerless, but their actual autonomy has not disappeared. And that distinction is fundamental because if somebody genuinely doesn't consent or withdraws their consent, we're no longer talking about consensual role play. We're talking about something entirely different. I know people who have spent weeks doing CNC scenes, planning them, organizing them, going step by step because it is very important. We know what we're doing, and there's safe words and maybe traphite colours, all of this safety. Or the rack, prick, SSC, um sick, all of the foundations to BDSM need to be there first. Something else worth mentioning is that not everybody who has CNC fantasies wants to act on them. Some people enjoy these scenarios entirely within their imagination. Others might enjoy reading about them, watching these scenarios with fictional betrayals or discussing them with a partner. And some people do choose to explore carefully negotiated role play. None of those things automatically tells us what someone wants to happen outside the fantasy. Well, they're certainly not as unusual as some people might assume. A study that was published in 2009 surveyed 355 female university students about fantasies involving sexual coercion. Around 62% reported having experienced a rape-related fantasy at some point. Now, that statistic needs some context. This was a particular university sample, not a representative survey of every woman. And reporting a fantasy doesn't mean somebody practices CNC. But what I find particularly interesting is that the researchers also looked at how women experience these fantasies emotionally. They weren't always described as entirely pleasurable or entirely unpleasant. Some participants reported fantasies containing a mixture of erotic and averse feelings. And I think that's fascinating. Because we tend to imagine sexual fantasy as something that should be completely straightforward. Something turns you on, therefore you must like it. Therefore, you must want it. But that's not necessarily how a fantasy works. A person can find a fictional scenario exciting while recognizing that the real-world equivalent would be horrifying. And that brings us to the question of why somebody might fantasize about losing control in the first place. But I'm gonna step in here and mention about books that have lots of smut and like dark romance, because that has a lot of CNC in it. Most of the time in smutty books, you are being pursued by somebody um who is potentially like a vampire, a werewolf, um, some rich guy, or somebody, a man usually, who won't suffer anything to pursue you and do things to you. And a lot of smutty books have some form of CNC in them. It might be really subtle, say the guy you barely know puts um his knee uh trying to spread your thighs or something, or puts his hand on your thighs. That's like a form of C and C because you didn't consent to that, but it's fantasy, and like that's in a lot of books, that is a lot of um romance which some women chase and get that dopamine hit in these books. It does not mean that we want to have this in real life in the open world, but it can make quite a lot of women very happy. So, why? Why CNC? One possible explanation is the appeal of surrender. Think about how much control we're expected to maintain in everyday life. We make decisions, manage responsibilities, deal with other people's expectations, and generally try to keep everything together. And for some people, the idea of temporarily handing over control can be appealing. Just like a submissive, it's the same thing. You don't want to think about the bills, about your job, about adulting. Within a consensual power exchange dynamic, someone may enjoy allowing another person to take the lead. Because choosing to surrender control can itself be an expression of autonomy. You're making a decision, you're establishing the boundaries, you're choosing who you're trusting. Unless you're reading or watching, but acting it out, you definitely need to do it with somebody who's trusted. So, although the fantasy might involve having no control, the reality is that you've exercised control by deciding whether to participate. But don't but I don't think we should assume everybody interested in CNC is secretly desperate to escape responsibility. That's one possible motivation, but not a universal explanation. There's never always one answer. On the flip side, another interesting possibility is the fantasy of being irresistibly desired. Some scenarios involving pursuit or overwhelming desire might be less about violence and more about the emotional experience of being wanted, just like those smutty books. And I think there's an important distinction here between wanting someone to find you irresistible and wanting someone to disregard your actual boundaries. Like in Fifty Shades of Grey, how grey became encapsulated with steel. Some people have fantasies of being wanted. I definitely think you should check out Secretary. It's a bit less toxic than Fifty Shades of Grey. Honestly, it's really, I don't really think I've seen a very good uh depiction of BDSM. Um, Secretary's great in a way. I can relate to it. We've spoken about this previously in a previous episode just about movies with BDSM. And yeah, Pillion is another BDSM movie. It's not great, it's not how like BDSM should be done or anything like that. Like that is like a warning um of just what a BDSM relationship should not be like. Um I think I do want to do a podcast episode on how bad Pillion is. But I get why people fantasize about it because it's got that like CNC aspect, but it kind of doesn't have consent in a way, because they don't really talk about it, but then it it's really quite toxic. The Dom is an asshole. Um yeah. Side note a fictional scenario might exaggerate the idea of somebody's desire to an extreme that would be completely unacceptable in reality. But within the fantasy, the emotional focus might be on desirability rather than harm. For somebody else, the attraction might be the taboo itself. Human sexuality doesn't always align neatly with what we consider sensible, appropriate, or desirable in everyday life. Sometimes people find fictional scenarios exciting precisely because they're outside their normal experiences. But again, that doesn't mean taboo is the explanation for everybody. One of the examples I'm gonna give for CNC is I have many clients online and in person who enjoy forced by. Now there can be many reasons for this, and this is a whole podcast episode in itself. Forced by. So forced by is forced bisexuality. It is where somebody, usually the bottom, the sub, the receiver, no, the give, yeah, the giver, not the receiver, um is consenting to being used to give another guy a blow job. Um, not necessarily it doesn't have to mainly be a guy, but it's most common for me to have a guy bottom or a guy submissive want to do force by. And so then I bring in another guy, but he is a top, he is something we call a bull, he is another thing like an alpha, and he has a penis, and he puts it in the guy's mouth or in the guy's ass. Consensually non-consent. The usually the bottom has asked for this. They want to do a forced by scene where there could be force, or yeah, you yeah, yeah, yeah, there's force. It's forced, it's forced by. So, yeah, the there is forcing, and it it for me it's very fun, and for the bottom, it can be very fun as well. Um, some people book me and they get too nervous, or they enjoy booking me, and that is like the fantasy, and then they cancel, or something like that, or they want to act it out um written rather than in person, and that's all completely fine and valid, and I really enjoy it. So that's one way. Um, one of the examples, one of the types of uh CNC. But yeah, in 2012, there was a study which examined several theories about why women might experience coercion-related sexual fantasies. One theory was sexual blame avoidance, the idea that imagining being forced could allow someone to experience sexual desire without feeling responsible for it. One thing which I noticed while researching up this um episode, it was really really hard to find just any studies on men who enjoyed for C and C, which I found was very, very interesting. One theory was sexual blame avoidance, the idea that imagining being forced could allow someone to experience sexual desire without feeling responsible for it. That's very fair, I understand that. Another involved sexual desirability, and another considered openness to sexual experience. Interestingly, the researchers found stronger support for openness to sexual experience than the theory that these fantasies primarily allow women to avoid responsibility for wanting sex. And I think that challenges a popular assumption. People sometimes imagine that women have these fantasies because they're ashamed of their sexuality, or because they need an excuse to enjoy sex. But the research doesn't support reducing everyone to that explanation. Perhaps instead of immediately asking what's wrong with somebody for having a particular fantasy, we should ask what that fantasy means to the person experiencing it. And sometimes they might not know, and that's okay. I think that's another thing worth thinking about. We don't always understand why something turns us on. Not every sexual interest has a clear explanation. I mean, for example, mine. I like CNC. I like to watch it, um, I like to read it. I've tried it in real life, um, role-playing it with a partner who I trust and things like that. And I don't know, I just don't think it's for me. I get like maybe like too panicky. Um I don't know. Maybe in the future I wanna try it again, but for now I enjoy it on a screen or in a book. Um, but I also have past trauma of sexual assault and rape, and so yeah, I think maybe it comes down to that as well, just the fact that I can do it in a safe space or I can watch it or read it, and I've got no pressure on myself. But as I said, there's there's many reasons why people like CNC. They don't same with sex work. We we ain't all like broken fucking humans where something tragic has happened and things. Not all of us. Me, maybe, but just just think about it. Okay. I don't necessarily think like every fantasy needs to be treated like a psychological puzzle that has to be solved. Of course, CNC also overlaps with something we've discussed before on Behind the Paddle, which is fair play. Definitely go check out that episode. There's a relationship between anticipation, uncertainty, vulnerability, and excitement. But we need to be careful not to suggest that fear automatically creates sexual arousal. Because it doesn't. And someone enjoying consensual, that's the big word here, fair play doesn't mean they would enjoy genuine danger. The context matters enormously. The person involved matters, trust matters, safety matters, boundaries matter, all of this, which is just the framework, the baseline of all BDSM. The knowledge that the situation is chosen rather than imposed can completely change how someone experiences it. Which brings us to one of the bigger assumptions people make about CNC. Trauma. One of the things that really frustrates me about how people discuss kink is this assumption that if somebody enjoys something outside of what's considered normal, of what's considered vanilla, there must be something wrong with them. And CNC seems to attract this assumption more than the most. If somebody fantasizes about being overpowered, people immediately want to know whether they've experienced sexual violence. It's none of their business, quite frankly. If somebody enjoys submission, people start wondering whether they've had some kind of childhood trauma. But why do we automatically assume that an unusual sexual fantasy must have a traumatic explanation? We don't normally demand that that somebody explain their entire psychological history because they enjoy a particular kind of vanilla sex. Like, why do you enjoy missionary? Hmm? Like why do you enjoy doggy, huh? Do you like that dog over there? You want to be in doggy that much. Oh my god, don't. So why do we do it with kink? Now that's not to say trauma can't influence sexuality. Of course, people's experience can shape how they relate to sex, intimacy, vulnerability, and control. But there's a massive difference between acknowledging that possibility and deciding that everybody with a particular fantasy must be traumatized. Some studies have identified associations between experiences of sexual abuse and particular kinds of coercion-related fantasies. But an association isn't proof of causation. And it certainly doesn't mean that everybody who experiences those fantasies has a history of abuse. We cannot reliably work backwards from somebody's sexual fantasy and decide what must have happened to them. There's also an interesting conversation around the idea of reclaiming control. Some people who've experienced trauma describe consensual power exchange as empowering. And I can understand why that raises interesting questions. If somebody has previously experienced a situation where their choices were taken away, could being able to establish boundaries and make their own decisions around a fantasy feel meaningful? Possibly. CNC isn't therapy, and it isn't automatically healing. One person might find an experience empowering, another might find it distressing, and somebody else might have no connection whatsoever between their kink and past experiences. We shouldn't assume that somebody is trying to recreate a trauma experience simply because they enjoy a particular fantasy. And you don't need to explore C and C to recover from trauma. One particularly influential figure was Richard von Kraff Ebbing, whose book Psychopathia Sexualis, I think, was first published in 1886. Kraff Ebbing attempted to classify sexual behaviors and interests that he regarded as abnormal. His work helped popularize the medical terms sadism and masochism. And the word masochism came from the name of another writer, Leopold von Satcher Masco, I think. His novel, Venus and Fers, published in 1870, explored a man's desire to submit to a woman. It dealt with domination, humiliation, power, and negotiation of a submissive relationship. This was in the 1800s, guys. And I think that's particularly interesting because it shows that fantasies involving voluntary surrender and power exchange were being explored in literature long before modern BDSM terminology became widespread. It's always been there. We've just put more names to it, and it's more known about now. It's like when your grandparents are like, oh, ADHD is everywhere, everybody's got it, and it's like, nan, you've got multiple different types of spoons all locked in a cabinet. Never mind the fine China, like, can we chill? ADHD and autism and things were very prevalent back in the day. We just notice them more now and talk about them more. Thankfully, there's more awareness. But it also raises another question. When did society stop treating unconventional sexual interests primarily as moral failings and start treating them as medical or physiological conditions? Of course, that transition wasn't straightforward. Religious condemnation and medical classification overlapsed. And being classified medically didn't necessarily mean people became more accepting. In some cases, it simply gave society a different vocabulary for judging sexuality. Then, moving into the twentieth century, we have the historical romance novels that became particularly popular during the 1970s and 1980s. Some featured powerful male characters, female resistance, forced seduction, and relationships that eventually became romantic. One notable example is Kathleen E. Woodywise, The Flame and the Flower published in 1972. It became an influential work in the modern historical romance genre, despite containing sexual violence and coercive elements. And I think it's worth asking why stories involving those themes appeal to readers. Was it the intensity of the romance? The power imbalance? The fantasy of being overwhelmingly desired? Or simply the opportunity to explore something forbidden through fiction? Are men not giving women the romance they want? We shouldn't pretend there's one established answer, and we certainly shouldn't assume that somebody who enjoys reading fictional scenarios wants to experience it in reality. But I think these stories show that the relationship between power, resistance, and desire has been part of sexual storytelling for a heck of a long time. Which brings us back to the modern CNC. Because although we can recognize similar themes throughout history, that doesn't mean every historical story involving cohesion is an example of consensual non-consent. Modern CNC depends on genuine agreement, and that distinction is so important and essential. One of the biggest misunderstandings about CNC is that people seem to think the whole point is consent disappears, but it doesn't. The fantasy might involve somebody appearing to have no control, but the reality should be that their boundaries and their right to stop are still respected. And that's an important distinction. Because if somebody agrees to a particular scenario, that doesn't mean they've given you unlimited permission to do whatever you want. It means they've agreed to something specific. And if they change their mind, that agreement can be withdrawn. Even if you get so close to starting the scene and they say, no, actually, I don't want to do it. Doesn't matter what the reason is. Respect them saying they don't want to do it. I think that's something which people need to understand before they even consider exploring CNC. That's how BDSM is, and that's how life should be if you're practicing BDSM or not. Like no means no. Because the difference between consensual role play and actual coercion isn't how convincing the scene looks. It's whether everybody involved has genuinely agreed to what's happening and remains free to stop. And this is where negotiation becomes particularly important. CNC requires somebody casually saying they're interested in a particular fantasy. People need to discuss what they're actually agreeing to. What are the boundaries? What activities are completely off limits? What language or scenarios might be uncomfortable? Are you having traffic like colours? So green, amber, red, are you I should hope you're having safe words no matter what, really? Um and with CNC, you don't have to like your safe word doesn't have to be stop. It can be like pineapple or something like that. Something like really out of pocket. So how will genuine withdrawal of consent be communicated? What happens if somebody becomes overwhelmed, distressed, like actually traumatized or triggered? Do you have a backup plan? Do you have aftercare sorted for them? Can you quickly comfort them in some way? Can you bring them back? A safe word can be an important tool, particularly when ordinary expressions of resistance have a fictional meaning within the role play. But it's not a substitute for paying attention to the other person. Somebody might become overwhelmed, freeze, panic, or struggle to communicate. And the absence of a safe word doesn't automatically mean everything is fine. You need to have those skills, you need to be able to know the person so well to be doing this. If somebody appears genuinely distressed or the meaning of the resistance becomes unclear, the scene needs to stop and consent needs to be checked somehow. Because sometimes people seem to imagine that being dominant means having absolute control. That you get to do whatever you want, but responsible power exchange doesn't work like that, especially with something like CNC. If somebody is placing themselves in a vulnerable position and trusting you to take the lead, that trust comes with responsibility. You still have to take care of them. You need to understand what's been agreed, recognize the boundaries, and be prepared to stop. It doesn't matter whether stopping interrupts the fantasy, it matters whether somebody agreed to something earlier. If the situation changes, that matters more than keeping the roleplay going. You want that person to still feel safe, to still feel that you respect them and you know they're safe around you. And something else I think doesn't get discussed enough is that dominants have boundaries too. Just because somebody wants to experience a particular fantasy doesn't mean the person they're asking has to be comfortable providing it. And I think sometimes people forget that. They'll talk about what they want a dominant to do, how far they want things to go, or what kind of scenario they imagine. But the dominant is also a person. They have their own comfort levels, their own limits, and their own right to say no. Consent isn't something that applies just to the submissive or the bottom. It applies to everybody involved. And being a DOM doesn't mean being willing to fulfill every fantasy that somebody brings you. Which leads us to something else that I think, you know, we need to talk about. We've spent a lot of time discussing why somebody might fantasize about being overpowered. But what about the other person on the other side? What about somebody who enjoys playing the aggressor? Because I think people can be very quick to make assumptions about what that says about somebody. If a person enjoys pretending to be controlling, intimidating, or forceful in a consensual sexual scenario, does that mean they actually want to behave that way towards people? Is that a true reflection of the person? Not necessarily. There's a difference between enjoying a fictional role and wanting to commit the real-world act that role presents. So I have been the Dom in many forced by sessions. Would I actually like just go out and force a guy to suck another guy off or get penetrated by another guy or me pretend that I have a real penis and non-consensually rape a guy? No. No. I like the power control. I like having that power for a however long amount of time, what, 30 minutes, an hour, maybe a little bit longer. I like it. It's fun. You get to do such taboo fantasies, which yeah, they're not normal. They're not vanilla. And I get to act out somebody's fantasy where they really might not be able to in the open world where some can't exactly they can, but it'll be a difficult conversation to ask their wives or partners or their date, hey, can you forcefully face fuck me with a strap on or get Big Dave over there to come and fuck me in the ass while I scream no. Like it's you know, it's not the norm. Um, it's not necessarily, you know, something you bring up. And I get that. I totally get that, which is why a lot of people go see sex workers and professional dominatrixes like myself, because it can be difficult, really, in the real world. Um, where this is totally seen as not normal and freakish and very taboo, and it sucks. But yeah, I enjoy it. Um I think also just being whichever role it is, I think it definitely helps with stress and it decompresses you and it honestly afterwards I get such a clearer mind. I I I like it. Think about how people engage with fictional characters. Someone might enjoy playing a villain in a theatrical production or reading stories about morally questionable characters. That doesn't automatically mean they endorse those characters' behaviors. And the sexual fantasies can also include roles that don't reflect somebody's everyday values. But I think the important question isn't simply whether somebody enjoys playing that role. It's how do you behave when the fantasy ends? Do they respect your boundaries? Do they accept no? Do they understand the difference between consensual power exchange and actual coercion? What is the aftercare routine afterwards? How are they gonna bring you back to real life, back into the space? Because those things tell us far more about somebody than the fact they enjoy a particular fantasy. One possible motivation for playing the dominant role is the experience of authority. All I can think about is Carpenter in my head just respect my authority, it is great. Some people enjoy taking the lead, directing an interaction or creating a situation in which another person voluntarily surrenders control. Others might enjoy the theoricality of the role. Oh my god, why can't I speak? Theatre acting or the psychological intensity, or the fact that somebody trusts them enough to explore a particular fantasy together. For me, that honestly fills my heart with so much joy that somebody is trusting me enough to ram a cock down their throat, and trust me that I won't go over their boundaries, I will listen to their limits, and it's it's fucking beautiful, honestly. It is. There is a difference between dominance and cruelty. Dominance within BDSM can involve a wide range of motivations. Some people enjoy structure and authority, some enjoy nurturing, guidance, or responsibility. Others enjoy strictness, intimidation, or theatrical aggression within agreed boundaries. And some enjoy a mixture. Calling yourself a dominant doesn't automatically make you safe or responsible. Anyone can use that label. What matters is how you treat people, and that's Especially important with CNC because somebody can use the language of kink to excuse genuinely coercive behavior. I mean, we've all heard it in rape cases or death cases where a male has this is what you usually hear where a male has killed a female and used the excuse of oh they like to be strangled. Consent, non-consent, strangulation. And it's like pretty sure you've just killed her, just like not with CNC. Um it actually takes quite a while to actually strangle somebody to death, like a good few minutes. Um so yeah, no, there there are people out there, and if somebody pressures another person to participate, ignores their boundaries, or treats genuine distress as part of the fantasy, that's that's a serious problem. That's not CNC, that's not BDSM. Enjoying simulated resistance within a negotiated scenario is not the same as enjoying somebody's actual inability to refuse. And I think that's one of the most important distinctions I really want to make on this episode. There's also an emotional side to playing the aggressor that doesn't always get discussed. Somebody might enjoy imagining them themselves in that role, but discover that actually performing it feels uncomfortable. They might worry about crossing a boundary, they might find a particular language upsetting, or they might simply decide that the fantasy is better left a fantasy. And that's completely good. That's fine. Just as a submissive can change their mind, a dominant can too. Nobody should feel pressured to participate in a scenario they're uncomfortable with. An aftercare is an important consideration which you do need to think about. Not every CNC scene ends with everybody feeling exactly how they expected. I tried it a few times and honestly for myself, depending on the act, I prefer fantasy. Even when something has been consensual and carefully negotiated, intense role play can bring up unexpected emotions. Somebody might feel vulnerable, embarrassed, unsettled, or simply exhausted. And the person who played the dominant role may have emotional reactions too. Aftercare might involve reassurance, conversations, quiet time, physical comfort if wanted, or checking in afterwards. There isn't one universal approach. We've definitely covered aftercare a good few times on this podcast, so I definitely encourage you to go look at previous episodes, but aftercare doesn't replace consent, and it can't make a non-consensual experience consensual after the fact. We also need to acknowledge that negotiation and preparation don't eliminate every risk. CNC can involve significant psychological and physical risks, and sometimes the responsible decision is not to proceed. That isn't a failure of a kink. It's respecting the people involved, and I think that brings us to a broader conversation about sexual shame. Because one of the strangest things about human sexuality is how much guilt people can feel over things that exist entirely outside their own imagination. You can have a fantasy you've never acted on, never intended to act on, and wouldn't even want to experience in real life. And yet you can still feel ashamed of it. CNC particularly is an interesting example because we're talking about fantasies involving situations most of us would recognize as completely unacceptable in reality. So somebody might find themselves wondering why on earth they find that idea sexually exciting, and trust me, I have been there and I still do not really understand it. Does it mean something about them? Does it mean they secretly want something terrible to happen? Does it mean they're a bad person? Because having a fantasy isn't the same as wanting to turn the fantasy into a reality. There's a psychological concept called thought action fusion. It describes a tendency to treat certain thoughts as morally equivalent to actions, or to believe that thinking about something makes it more likely to happen. It's a concept studied particularly in relation to obsessive compulsive symptoms. Now I'm not suggesting people who feel ashamed of their sexual fantasies of OCD, but I think the distinction between thoughts and actions here is useful. Thinking about something isn't the same as doing it. And having an uncomfortable or unusual fantasy doesn't automatically tell us what somebody intends to do. If somebody enjoys watching horror films, we don't automatically assume they want to be murdered. If somebody enjoys reading crime fiction, we don't automatically assume they want to commit crimes. So why do we sometimes make those assumptions about sexual fantasy? Of course there are differences between fictional violence and sexual role play involving real people. Consent and behavior still matter, but I think the comparison helps demonstrate why we shouldn't always interpret fantasies literally. And CNC attracts particularly strong reactions because it deliberately resembles situations involving genuine sexual violence. I understand why people find that uncomfortable. Sexual violence causes real harm, and concerns about people misusing CNC terminology to excuse abuse are legitimate. Some people will never feel comfortable with CNC, even as fantasy. And that's their right to feel like that. Nobody has to enjoy it, nobody's forcing you to. Nobody has to participate in it. And nobody has to approve of somebody else's sexual interests. But I think there's a difference between saying that's not something I would ever want to do, and deciding that everybody who has that fantasy must be dangerous or psychologically damaged. We can recognize that a subject is intense without automatically condemning the people who are interested in it. And equally, we can support consensual kink without pretending that every situation describes that every situation described as BDSM is automatically ethical. Because ultimately the thing that matters isn't simply what somebody finds exciting. It's how they treat other people. Are they communicating? Are they respecting boundaries? And this goes for both top bottom dom, both people who are playing together in a relationship, you know, all that stuff. Are they respecting boundaries? Is everybody involved genuinely choosing to participate? Because somebody can have a fantasy that sounds incredibly dark and still be respectful responsible person. No, ignore that. Because somebody can have a fantasy that sounds incredibly dark and still be a respectful, responsible person. And that somebody else can describe themselves as completely vanilla and still behave abusively. The label somebody gives their sexuality doesn't tell you whether they're a decent person. Their behaviour does. I also think that we need to stop assuming that every sexual fantasy needs an explanation. We've spent this episode looking at psychological terms, historical influences, and possible motivations, but not everybody knows why they find something exciting. And sometimes a fantasy might not have any deeper meaning that the person can identify. One person might connect CNC to trust, another might connect it to being taboo. Someone else might find the fantasy appealing without attaching any particular psychological significance to it. And somebody might enjoy imagining CNC but have absolutely no interest in practicing it. Not every fantasy needs solving. And I don't think people should feel they have to uncover some hidden psychological explanation before they're allowed to understand or accept their own sexuality. Sometimes understanding that a fantasy can remain a fantasy is enough. So after everything we've discussed today, what can we actually say about CNC? Consensual non-consent? Well, first of all, it's a lot more complicated than simply wanting to be dominated or wanting to dominate somebody. We've looked at why some people might find the idea of surrendering control exciting, why others might enjoy taking a more aggressive role, and how themes involving power and resistance have appeared throughout history. We've also looked at the assumptions people make about trauma, mental health, and what sexual fantasies supposedly reveal about us. And I think one of the biggest takeaways of all is that our fantasies don't always reflect what we want in real life. Sometimes people enjoy imagining situations they would never want to experience. Sometimes the fantasy is about power. Sometimes it's about surrender. Sometimes it's about taboo. And sometimes people simply don't know why a particular idea appeals to them. And I don't think we necessarily need an explanation for every single thing that turns us on. But there is something we absolutely need to understand, which is consent. Because one last time, the entire distinction between C and C and actual sexual coercion depends on it. The fantasy might involve somebody appearing to have no control, but that doesn't mean they've genuinely surrendered their right to make decisions about their own body. And being dominant doesn't mean having unlimited permission to do whatever you want. Everybody involved still has boundaries. Everybody still has choices. And everybody has the right to stop. I think we can have conversations about darker sexual fantasies without either demonizing the people who enjoy them or pretending that there are no risks involved. And perhaps that what that's what makes CNC such an interesting subject. It forces us to confront the difference between what we imagine and what we desire and what we actually choose to do. Because ultimately, the important part of consensual non-consent isn't the fact isn't the fantasy of having no control. It's the fact that the choice was yours in the first place. Rape is rape, it's non consensual. I hope I've made that very clear.